The Positive List Approach and the Legality Principle in Criminal Law in the European Union



Paraules clau:

CITES, Illegal wildlife trade, Positive lists, Principle of legality in Criminal Law


In the context of a critical review of CITES as an instrument that deals with the trafficking of species of wildlife fauna and flora, this paper intends to analyse the legislative strategy of positive lists as an alternative to the negative lists approach used by CITES, from the perspective of criminal law. From the perspective of criminal law, it is important to analyse the problems this legislative strategy may pose when regulating crimes, or enforcing them in courts. This work focusses on a fundamental question: Could a reference to positive lists in the description of offences raise issues about constitutionality in national courts due to violation of the legality principal in criminal law? The conclusion is that, indeed, the reference to positive lists in the description of an offence could raise issues in the courts for violation of the legality principle in criminal law.


Les dades de descàrrega encara no estan disponibles.


AAP Animal Advocacy and Protection y Eurogrup for Animals, Think Positive. Why Europe needs ‘positive lists’ to regulate the sale and keeping of exotic animals as pets (sin fecha). Disponible en: <> [última consulta, 29 de abril de 2021].

Altherr, Sandra, Lameter, Katharina, “The Rush for the Rare: Reptiles and Amphibians in the European Pet Trade”, en Animals 2020, 10(11), 2085.

Altherr, Sandra, Lameter, Katharina, Stolen Wildlife III – The EU, a main hub and destination for illegally caught exotic pets, Pro Wildlife. Munich, 2020.

Baker, Sandra E., Cain, Russ, van Kesteren, Freya, Zommers, Zinta A., D’Cruze, Neil and Macdonald, David W., “Rough trade: animal welfare in the global wildlife trade”, BioScience, vol. 63, núm. 12, 2013, p. 928–938.

Bonelli, Matteo, “The Taricco saga and the consolidation of judicial dialogue in the European Union: CJEU, C-105/14 Ivo Taricco and others, ECLI:EU:C:2015:555; and C-42/17 M.A.S., M.B., ECLI:EU:C:2017:936 Italian Constitutional Court, Order no. 24/2017”, en Maastricht Journal of European andComparative Law, vol. 25, núm. 3, 2018, p. 357–373.

Byung-Sun Cho, “Emergence of an International Environmental Criminal Law?”, en UCLA Journal of Environmental Law and Policy, vol. 19, 2000/2001, p. 11-47.

Comisión Europea, Comunicación de la Comisión al Parlamento Europeo, al Consejo, al Comité Económico y Social Europeo y al Comité de las Regiones: Programa de trabajo de la Comisión para 2021, COM(2020) 690 final.

Correcher Mira, Jorge, Principio de legalidad penal: ley formal vs law in action, Tirant lo Blanch. Valencia, 2018.

De la Fuente Cardona, Francisco Salvador, “De Kononov a Vasiliauskas y el principio de legalidad penal a la luz del Convenio Europeo de Derechos Humanos: o por qué acierta en su análisis el voto particular del juez Pinto de Alburquerque en el asunto Ilnseher c. Alemania”, en Revista Electrónica de Estudios Penales y de la Seguridad, núm. 7 (especial), 2021, p. 1-19.

De Volder, Sofie, McLennan, Staci, Schmit, Véronique, Analysis of national legislation related to the keeping and sale of exotic pets in Europe, Eurogrup for Animals. Brussels, 2013.

EPO et al., “An open letter to national and international governing bodies regarding NGO calls to end live animal trade in response to the Covid-19 pandemic”, 2020. Disponible en: <> [última consulta, 29 de abril de 2021].

EPO, EPO position on positive lists of animals that can be trade, 2012. Disponible en: <> [última consulta, 29 de abril de 2021].

European Commission, Commission Staff Working Document Evaluation of the Directive 2008/99/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 19 November 2008 on the protection of the environment through criminal law, SWD (2020) 259 final, Part 1.

European Criminal Policy Initiative, “Manifiesto sobre la política criminal europea”, (2009), disponible en Versión actualizada publicada en European Criminal Law Review, núm. 1, 2011, p. 86-103.

Fajardo del Castillo, Teresa, “The European Union's Approach in the Fight against Wildlife Trafficking: Challenges Ahead”, en Journal of International Wildlife Law & Policy, vol. 19, núm. 1, 2016, p. 1-21.

Faure, Michael, “Vague notions in environmental criminal law (part 1)”, en Environmental Liability, vol.4, 2010, p. 119-133.

Faure, Michael, “Vague notions in environmental criminal law (part 2)”, Environmental Liability, vol. 5, 2010, p. 163-170.

García Álvarez, Pastora; López Peregrín, Carmen, “Los delitos contra la flora, la fauna y los animales domésticos. Análisis doctrinal y jurisprudencial, con referencia a la reforma introducida por la LO 5/2010, de 22 de junio”, en Revista Electrónica de Ciencia Penal y Criminología. 2013, núm. 15-11, p. 11:1-11:65.

Hava García, Esther, La protección penal de los animales, Tirant lo Blanch, 2009.

IPBES, “Workshop Report on Biodiversity and Pandemics”, Bonn, 2020.

Krämer, Ludwig, “Forty Years of EU Measures to Fight Wildlife Crime”, en Journal of International Wildlife Law & Policy, vol. 22, núm. 4, 2019, p. 305-331.

Maher, Jennifer; Sollund, Ragnhild, “Wildlife trafficking: Harms and Victimization”, en Ragnhild Sollund, Christoph H. Stefes, Anna Rita Germani (eds.), Fighting Environmental Crime in Europe and Beyond. Palgrave Studies in Green Criminology, Palgrave Macmillan. London, 2016, p. 99-128.

Marquès-Banqué, Maria, “Environmental Crime. Assessing and enhancing EU compliance with international environmental law”, en Mar Campins Eritja (ed.), The European Union and Global Environmental Protection. Transforming Influence into Action, Routledge. New York, 2021, p. 132-148.

Marquès-Banqué, Maria, “Problemas de persecución del tráfico internacional de fauna silvestre: la ilicitud solo en origen”, en María Luisa Cuerda Arnau (dir.) y Juan José Periago Morant (coord.), De animales y normas. Protección animal y derecho sancionador, Tirant lo Blanch. Valencia, 2021, p. 225-255.

Marques-Banque, Maria, “The utopia of the harmonization of legal frameworks to fight against transnational organized environmental crime”, en Sustainability, 10(10) 3576, 2018.

Matallín, Ángela, Delitos relativos a la protección de la biodiversidad, Tirant lo Blanch. Valencia, 2013.

Nurse, Angus, Wyatt, Tanya, Wildlife Criminology, Bristol University Press. Bristol, 2020.

OMS, FAO, OIE, Taking Multisectoral, One Health Approach: A Tripartite Guide to Addressing Zoonotic Deseases in Countries, 2019.

Pereira, Ricardo M., “The external dimensions of the EU legislative initiatives to combat environmental crime”, en Spanish Yearbook of International Law, vol.19, 2015, p. 251-268.

Perilongo, Giovanni F., Corn, Emanuele, en New Journal of European Criminal Law vol. 8, núm. 2, 2017, p. 236–255.

Peristeridou, Christina, The Principle of Legality in European Criminal Law, Intersentia. Cambridge, 2015.

Ragaišytė, Ieva Marija “Challenges in harmonising and implementing the environmental crime Directive”, en Teisé-Vilnius University Press, vol. 118, 2021, p. 130-144.

Reuter, Peter, O’Regan, Davin, “Smuggling wildlife in the Americas: scale, methods, and links to other organised crimes”, en Global Crime, vol. 18, núm. 2, 2017, p. 77- 99.

Sicurella, Rosaria, “La creación de una cultura penal europea: en la confianza confiamos”, en Rosaria Sicurella, Valsamis Mitsilegas, Raphaële Parizot, Analisa Lucifora (eds.), Principios generales del Derecho penal en la Unión Europea, BOE. Madrid, 2020, p. 27-51.

Sicurella, Rosaria; Costa, Martina, “El principio de legalidad”, en Rosaria Sicurella, Valsamis Mitsilegas, Raphaële Parizot, Analisa Lucifora (eds.), Principios generales del Derecho penal en la Unión Europea, BOE. Madrid, 2020, p. 53-95.

Sina, Stephan, Gerstetter, Christiane, Porsch, Lucas, Roberts, Ennid, O’ Smith, Lucy, Klaas, Katharina, Fajardo, Teresa, Wildlife crime, European Parliament. Brussels, 2016.

Sollund, Ragnhild, The crimes of wildlife trafficking: Issues of justice, legality and morality, Routledge. Abingdon, Oxon, 2019.

Timmerman, Mikhel, Legality in Europe: On the Principle Nullum Crimen, Nulla Poena Sine Lege in EU law and Under the ECHR, Intersentia. Cambridge, 2018.

Toland, Elaine, Bando, Monica, Hamers, Michèle, Cadenas, Vanessa, Laidlaw, Rob, Martínez-Silvestre, Albert y van der Wielen, Paul, “Turning negatives into positives for pet trading and keeping: a review of positive lists”, en Animals 2020, 10(12), 2371.

UNEP e International Livestock Research Institute, Preventing the Next Pandemic: Zoonotic diseases and how to break the chain of transmission, Nairobi, 2020.

UNODC, World Wildlife Crime Report. Trafficking in protected species, 2020. Disponible en: <> [última consulta, 29 de abril de 2021].

Van Uhm, Daan, "Illegal Wildlife Trade to the EU and Harms to the World", en Spapens, Toine, White, Rob, Huisman, Wim (eds.), Environmental Crime in Transnational Context; Routledge. New York, 2016, p. 43-66.

Van Uhm, Daan, The illegal wildlife trade: Inside the world of poachers, smugglers and traders, Springer Nature. New York, 2016.

White, Rob, Environmental harm: An eco-justice perspective, Policy Press. Bristol, 2013.

Wyatt, Tanya, Is CITES protecting wildlife? Assessing implementation and compliance, Routledge. New York, 2021.

Wyatt, Tanya, van Uhm, Daan, Nurse, Angus, “Differentiating criminal networks in the illegal wildlife trade: organized, corporate and disorganized crime”, en Trends in Organized Crime, vol. 23, 2020, p. 350-366.




Com citar

Marquès i Banqué, M. (2021). The Positive List Approach and the Legality Principle in Criminal Law in the European Union. Revista Catalana De Dret Ambiental, 12(1).




Articles més llegits del mateix autor/a

1 2 3 > >>